Exploring the adoption and impact of real-time payments in the financial landscape

February 19th, 2024

Fintech companies have emerged as significant players in the finance industry, bringing about transformative changes in how individuals and businesses manage their funds. One noteworthy development is the rise of Account-to-Account (A2A) payments. These payments offer a secure, cost-effective, and efficient method of transferring money between bank accounts, bypassing the need for intermediaries. This innovation highlights a substantial gap where traditional banking systems have fallen short.

The Achilles' heel of traditional banking lies in the prolonged duration it takes for bank-to-bank payments to clear. This timeframe can vary from several hours to days, posing a hindrance to the seamless flow of transactions for individuals and businesses alike.

"Payments are essential for everyday life, and too often, low- and moderate-income households and small businesses don't have access to the payment services they need at a reasonable cost." – Michael S. Barr, Vice Chair of the Federal Reserve

Real-time payments (RTP) have emerged as a revolutionary force in the financial realm, promising instant, secure, and frictionless transactions. While RTP has gained considerable traction globally, its adoption in some countries, such as the United States, has been relatively slow compared to other developed nations.

How RTPs succeed over ACH & wire transfers

Real-time payments are bank-to-bank transfers that occur within seconds, regardless of the time. This boosts transparency and confidence in transactions, benefiting consumers, banks, and businesses.

RTP exclusively supports credit or 'push' payments, meaning you cannot debit another person's account using RTP. Since funds are transferred instantly, all payments are final and non-reversible. This eliminates payment failures due to insufficient funds, a frequent occurrence with ACH.

Unlike Automated Clearing House (ACH) and wire transfers, RTP is available year-round, including weekends, bank holidays, and outside of business hours. Unlike batch processing in those systems, RTP provides immediate processing.

It's important to note that all RTP payments are processed by the clearing house. When you make an RTP payment, your bank sends a message to the network containing payment details. The clearing house then processes the message and routes it to the recipient's bank, completing the payment.

Positive key trends in real-time payments

Speed and availability – RTP enables instant transaction processing, ensuring users can send and receive funds anytime, day or night.
Enhanced user experience – Adopting real-time payments provides a seamless and convenient experience, allowing for instant payments and transfers, leading to higher customer satisfaction and increased financial flexibility.
Increased competition – The widespread adoption of real-time payment systems intensifies competition among financial institutions, driving them to enhance services and innovate.
Growing popularity of financial inclusion – RTP payments promote financial inclusion by offering a more accessible way to conduct transactions, particularly benefiting individuals in underserved or remote areas without easy access to traditional banking services.
Pressures for higher liquidity – With instant transactions, institutions must ensure sufficient funds are available to facilitate quick transfers, reducing the risk of delays or transaction failures.
Reduced OPEX costs – Real-time payment systems often result in reduced operational expenses (OPEX) for businesses and financial institutions. The automation and efficiency of these systems lead to cost savings through reduced manual processing, paperwork, and associated administrative tasks.

Where are RTPs used?

RTPs have gained global recognition and adoption, with several countries leading the way in implementing these innovative payment systems, paving the path for worldwide expansion. For instance, as early as 1973, Japan introduced the Zengin System, operated by the Japanese Bankers Association, revolutionising real-time payment capabilities.

Following suit, between 2004 and 2010, Mexico, South Africa, Chile, the United Kingdom, and China launched their own RTP networks, recognising the immense potential of instantaneous transactions and enhanced financial services.

In subsequent years, additional countries joined the movement, expanding the reach of RTPs. Sweden, Norway, Denmark, and Thailand, all rolled out their real-time payment systems in the early to mid-2010s.

These trailblazing nations have set the stage for the global proliferation of RTPs, reshaping the landscape of financial transactions and setting new standards for speed, efficiency, and customer satisfaction.

The United States' journey in adopting RTPs

The United States has followed a more gradual path in adopting RTPs compared to other developed nations. The US launched its real-time payment initiative in 2017 with the introduction of The Clearing House's RTP network. Despite the later start, the nation is steadily catching up and expanding the availability of real-time payment capabilities to consumers, banks, and businesses across the country.

Legacy infrastructure

The legacy infrastructure of the US financial system, including the ACH network, is a significant hurdle to the adoption of real-time payments (RTP). The ACH network is a batch-based system that processes transactions multiple times a day. This means that there can be delays in the settlement of transactions. Additionally, many businesses and consumers are accustomed to using the ACH network for their payments. This can make it difficult to convince them to switch to RTP.

Integration costs

Financial institutions face substantial costs when implementing RTP capabilities, including integrating new technologies and adapting existing systems. These upfront expenses can deter smaller institutions, especially when the potential return on investment is uncertain.

Lack of uniform standards

The absence of universally accepted standards for real-time payments (RTP) in the US has resulted in industry fragmentation. This lack of standardisation hampers interoperability and complicates the seamless adoption of RTP across different financial institutions.

Regarding the Federal Reserve's historical role in physically transporting checks, the evolution toward digital payments underscores the need for innovation to meet the demands of a rapidly changing financial landscape.

"Not that long ago, the Federal Reserve was facilitating payments by moving bundles of checks around the country on trucks and trains!" - Michael S. Barr, Vice Chair of the Federal Reserve.

The Federal Reserve envisions the FedNow Service as a complement to existing private sector instant payment services. This collaborative approach aims to enhance customer service by providing individuals with immediate access to their paychecks, eliminating the waiting period of traditional check processing.

"I view the FedNow Service as complementary to the private sector instant payment services offered today, and as banks build on these rails, customers can get better service. Individuals could have instant access to their paychecks and be able to spend them the same day, rather than waiting several days for checks to process." - Michael S. Barr, Vice Chair of the Federal Reserve.

The future of RTPs

The acceptance of universally accepted standards for RTP standards may vary, but some countries have achieved broad adoption.

United Kingdom – The Faster Payments Service (FPS) allows near-instantaneous electronic fund transfers between financial institutions, facilitating rapid financial transactions.
Australia – The New Payments Platform (NPP) enables real-time payments for both individuals and businesses, providing a streamlined payment infrastructure.
Sweden – Swish, a widely used mobile payment solution, facilitates real-time transactions between individuals and businesses, fostering a cashless ecosystem.
Singapore – The Fast and Secure Transfers (FAST) system provides a robust platform for real-time interbank transfers, enhancing efficiency and convenience.
Canada – The Real-Time Rail (RTR) initiative seeks to modernise the payments infrastructure by enabling real-time interbank settlements, particularly for high-value transactions.
Eurozone – The European Central Bank's Euro Retail Payments Board (ERPB) initiative aims to promote pan-European instant payments by establishing common standards and facilitating cross-border transactions.

As for the United States; the Federal Reserve envisions the FedNow Service as a complement to existing private sector instant payment services. This collaborative approach aims to enhance customer service, providing individuals with immediate access to their paychecks, and eliminating the waiting period associated with traditional check processing.

The convergence of Fintech innovations and real-time payments represents a pivotal moment in the financial landscape. As the industry grapples with legacy systems, integration challenges, and the imperative for standardised approaches, the vision of instant, secure, and frictionless transactions remains a driving force for change. This evolution is not only inevitable but also essential for creating a financial ecosystem that caters to the diverse needs of businesses in the digital age.

By addressing the lack of uniform standards and embracing collaborative approaches like the FedNow Service, the financial industry can enhance customer service and provide individuals with immediate access to their funds, eliminating the waiting period associated with traditional check processing. As we move forward, innovating and adapting to the changing demands, we can create a more efficient, inclusive, and customer-centric financial system.

In this article